Canmora Institute Canmora Institute

Canmora Institute update, November 2026

A public test for the AI government uses on people

In January 2020, Detroit police arrested Robert Williams at his home in Farmington Hills, in front of his wife and young daughters. Police said he had stolen watches from a store in downtown Detroit two years earlier. The only evidence was a facial recognition match between his old driver’s license photo and grainy store video. He spent about 30 hours in jail, and prosecutors later dropped the charges. In 2024 the city settled his lawsuit for $300,000 and agreed that its police can no longer arrest anyone on a facial recognition match alone.

He was not the only one. In early 2025, a Washington Post investigation found at least eight people wrongly arrested after a facial recognition match. It also found that people often never learn AI helped identify them, because prosecutors are not required to tell them. Police and other agencies now use AI in decisions like these, and the public often cannot see where. On November 3, Jim Townsend, who directs the Levin Center for Oversight and Democracy at Wayne State University Law School, and I proposed a standard in The Hill. Here is part of what we wrote:

State and federal agencies are now using artificial intelligence to help decide a host of life-altering issues such as who gets investigated for a crime and how law enforcement and the military direct their immense power. In most cases, no legislature voted to allow its use, no list tells the public what AI systems are being employed to help make these decisions, and no one knows for sure who can turn them off.

Hundreds of new lawmakers will take office in Congress and the states in January, many of whom campaigned on doing something to protect Americans from the risks of AI. We recommend they use their oversight and legislative powers to ensure that any AI system government uses to shape decisions about people’s lives and liberty is transparent, approved and stoppable. “Transparent” means its use and the underlying specifics appear on a list available to anyone. “Approved” means no AI system in government can go live unless it has been authorized through legislation or tested for safety and security using criteria in law. “Stoppable” means a named official answers for its use and that the decisions it makes can be undone.

Excerpted from “Transparent, approved and stoppable: A standard for government’s use of AI” by Jim Townsend and Patrick Carter, originally published in The Hill on November 3, 2026. Read the full piece in The Hill.

What comes next

That test is the starting point for Canmora Institute’s work. We are turning it into a public standard, starting with transparency, and once it is published we will assess state and federal laws and policies against it.

If you would like the standard when it is released, sign up for updates below.

All updates